As Martha Stewart’s longtime makeup artist, Daisy Toye knows a good thing when she sees it.
And while its rare to get confirmation on the 83-year-old star’s beauty secrets, Toye’s under-the-radar ShopMy storefront currently features a collection of “Martha’s favorites.”
Below, shop standouts from the beauty pro’s picks, from 24-karat gold eye patches to several drugstore favorites that’ll cost you less than $15 each.
Stewart’s long praised the powers of SPF — and while she’s name-dropped a few favorite sunscreens over the years, this combination skincare, sunscreen and skin tint made the cut for Toye’s roundup.
Not all of Toye’s product picks cost a mint, as this under-$10 mascara is currently on sale for just $8.
While Stewart used several Merit products in a sponsored “under-five-minute” makeup routine video earlier this year, it seems she’s using the brand’s wares while off the clock, too. Toye highlighted this shimmering balm — which comes backed by over 3,000 largely glowing reviews — in her roundup.
Stewart’s not the only mogul using Ami Colé products, as Oprah’s highlighted the brand on multiple of her famed “Favorite Things” lists.
The domestic doyenne’s also in good company when it comes to these hydrating eye patches; Kyle Richards called them her “fave” on Amazon Live, while Lindsay Lohan and Selena Gomez have both captured social media content while wearing theirs.
Don’t gloss over this Stewart-approved plumping lip gloss, sold in both clear and tinted versions.
While this Merit lip liner just launched in March, it’s already on Stewart’s radar. (Not to mention we’ve spotted it on everyone from Aimee Lou Wood to Tracee Ellis Ross.)
Eyeing Stewart’s eyeshadow? Toye linked this long-lasting Bobbi Brown stick that’s perfect for creating a smudged smoky eye look.
Back in 2023, Toye told People she used this glow lotion on Stewart for her history-making Sports Illustrated Swimsuit shoot.
“It’s how she gets that dewy look, like she just got a facial,” she added. “I’m obsessed with it.”
This travel-friendly product functions as both foundation and concealer.
Lancôme’s classic bronzer also got Toye’s stamp of approval, along with the brand’s Lash Idôle Mascara.
Stewart put her famed thirst-trap powers to use for a MAC campaign earlier this year, shooting a steamy ASMR video where she said the brand’s lipstick “smells like vanilla.”
Why Trust Page Six Style Shopping
This article was written by Hannah Southwick, Commerce Writer/Reporter for Page Six Style. Hannah spies deals on actually affordable celebrity-worn styles, puts Hollywood’s favorite labels to the test and finds the beauty products that keep stars red carpet-ready. She consults stylists and industry pros — including celebs themselves — for firsthand product recommendations, trend predictions and more. In addition to writing for Page Six since 2020, her work has been featured in USA Today and Parade.
Leave a Reply